Open Today Sales: 9 AM-6 PMOpen Today Service: 7 AM-6 PM
Same vehicle, two powertrains, one real trade: the gas model tows 5,000 pounds, the hybrid returns about 36 mpg. We sell both, so we are not going to tell you one wins.
Everything not listed here is the same on both. Same body, same seating, same safety suite, same standard all-wheel drive.
| Highlander (Gas) | Highlander Hybrid | |
|---|---|---|
| Engine | 2.4L turbocharged four | 2.5L four with hybrid system |
| Horsepower | 265 hpMore power | 243 hp net combined |
| Torque | 310 lb-ftMore torque | Not published as a combined figure |
| Transmission | 8-speed automatic | Electronically controlled CVT |
| Fuel economy (EPA est.) | 21 city / 28 hwy / 24 combined | About 36 combinedFar better mileage |
| Max towing | 5,000 lbs1,500 lbs more | 3,500 lbs |
| Drivetrain | AWD standard | AWD standard |
| Trims offered | XLE, XSE, Limited, Platinum | XLE, Limited, Platinum |
| Safety suite | Toyota Safety Sense 2.5+ | Toyota Safety Sense 2.5+ |
| Plug in? | Not applicable | No, conventional hybrid |
The right answer is set by what you do on weekends, not by which spec sheet reads better.
Five thousand pounds against three thousand five hundred is not a rounding difference. It is the line between pulling a mid-size boat comfortably and being at the edge of the rating.
If you tow, this page is already over. Take the gas model. The hybrid's fuel economy cannot buy back a tow rating you need on a Saturday morning at the Lake Tuscaloosa ramp, and nobody enjoys towing at the limit of what a vehicle is rated for.
The hybrid runs roughly $1,600 to $2,000 above the comparable gas trim. Going from 24 mpg combined to about 36 is a real gap, and on a 60-mile-each-way Birmingham commute it closes that premium reasonably quickly.
On a five-mile run to Northport and back, it does not, and we will tell you so. Buying a hybrid you do not drive enough to use is just a more expensive Highlander. Work out your actual annual miles first.
Toyota dropped the LE for 2026 and made all-wheel drive standard on everything. The XLE is now where the lineup starts.
| Trim | Gas starting MSRP | Hybrid starting MSRP | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| XLE | $45,870 | $47,620 | Entry trim. 8-inch display, heated front seats, wireless charging. |
| XSE | $47,640 | Not offered | Sport-styled with black accents. Gas only, so the trim decides the powertrain. |
| Limited | $51,920 | $51,775 | Dual 12.3-inch displays, JBL audio, leather, heated and ventilated fronts. |
| Platinum | $55,120 | $55,275 | Panoramic roof, Panoramic View Monitor, head-up display. |
Prices shown are Manufacturer's Suggested Retail Price (MSRP) and exclude tax, title, license, registration, destination and dealer documentation fees. MSRP figures were compiled from Toyota and reputable third-party sources and vary slightly between them, so confirm against Toyota's Build and Price tool. Fuel economy and towing figures are manufacturer or EPA estimates and vary with configuration and conditions. Inventory changes weekly, so call to confirm which trims are in stock.
We are at 3325 Skyland Blvd E, just off I-20 and I-59. The turbo and the hybrid feel different from the first hundred feet, and that is genuinely the fastest way to end this decision.
Sales is open 9 AM to 6 PM Monday through Friday and until 5:30 PM Saturday. Coming from Birmingham, Hoover or Bessemer? Call (205) 553-3325 ahead and we will have one of each waiting.
If your third row carries adults rather than occasional kids, look at the Grand Highlander before you decide between these two. Start a trade-in valuation or an online credit application whenever you are ready.
The hybrid costs roughly $1,600 to $2,000 more than the comparable gas trim and returns about 36 mpg combined against the gas model's 24. Whether that pays back depends entirely on your annual mileage. A 60-mile-each-way Birmingham commuter gets there quickly. Someone driving five miles to Northport and back does not.
The gas Highlander, and by a wide margin. It is rated up to 5,000 pounds against the hybrid's 3,500. If you pull a boat to Lake Tuscaloosa or a camper toward Bankhead National Forest, that 1,500-pound gap is the single most important line on this page.
No. For 2026 Toyota made all-wheel drive standard across the entire Highlander lineup, gas and hybrid alike. Toyota also dropped the LE trim, so the XLE is now the entry point. If you are cross-shopping an older listing, that is why the specs look different.
The gas model. Its 2.4-liter turbo makes 265 horsepower and 310 lb-ft against the hybrid's 243 net combined horsepower. The turbo also delivers its torque in a way that feels stronger merging onto I-20. The hybrid is smoother in town, but it is not the faster vehicle.
No. It is a conventional hybrid that charges its own battery through the engine and regenerative braking. There is no plug and no charging to arrange, which matters if you park on a street or in a campus deck near the University of Alabama.
Hybrid is offered on XLE, Limited and Platinum. The sport-styled XSE is gas only, so if you want the blacked-out sporty look, the hybrid is not an option. That is the one place where the trim you want may decide the powertrain for you.
Better than the gas model does. Stopped in the crawl off Paul W. Bryant Drive, the hybrid shuts its engine off rather than idling. Seven home Saturdays will not pay for the vehicle, but it is the same mechanism that makes the hybrid cheaper to run in daily Tuscaloosa traffic.
No. The Grand Highlander is a separate, longer vehicle with a third row adults can actually use and more cargo room behind it. If your third row carries adults rather than occasional kids, look at the Grand Highlander instead of choosing between these two.
Yes, and it settles the question faster than any spec sheet. The turbo and the hybrid feel genuinely different pulling out of our lot onto Skyland Boulevard. Call (205) 553-3325 and we will have one of each ready when you get here.
Answer that one honestly and the Highlander picks itself. Come drive both and check.
Tuscaloosa Toyota | 3325 Skyland Blvd E, Tuscaloosa, AL 35405
